CarMats.co.uk

Travel Disruptions: Exploring The Cause & Effect Transport Delays Have on Brits

Posted by Victoria Collins on

Every day across the UK, traffic delays and road congestion stop Brits’ in their tracks. Whether it’s bad driving, vehicle collisions or the state of the road causing chaos, travel disruptions cause over 1 in 6 Brits to lose over 2 hours each week to traffic. 

The Travel Disruptions Study delves into the nation’s travelling experiences, to reveal the most common causes of transport delay in the UK and how this impacts Brits. 

The study explores the areas and roads with the worst delays, the areas with the most collisions, and the roads and the demographics that cause the most accidents. Off-road, the study also explores the busiest stations and the train services with the worst delays. 

The results revealed:

  • 1 in 6 Brits spend over 2 days in traffic a year and Edinburgh is ‘worst’ city for being stuck in traffic 
  • Craven Arms area of the A49 in Shropshire has the worst traffic time in the UK 
  • Kent is the worst area for car accidents while Isle of Scilly has the least and the City of London had the best per population ratio. 
  • Brits in their 30s caused the most car accidents & women in their late teens & 70s caused the least
  • Durham has least efficient train service in the UK & Grand Central is worst performing rail operator
  • Lost Travel Time  

    1 in 6 Brits will lose 4 months of their life in traffic

    This is how long the average Brit spends in traffic

    Following a nationwide CarMats.co.uk study, research revealed over a third of Brits are stuck in traffic for 26 hours a year, losing over a half an hour a week and over a day a year to waiting around. Over 1 in 6 also reported being stuck in traffic for 2 hours a week, resulting in over 2 days lost each year to jams.

    Time spent in traffic per week

    %

    Less than 15 mins

    26%

    15 - 30 mins

    23%

    31 mins - 1 hour

    17%

    More than 1 hour, up to 2 hours

    9%

    More than 2, up to 3 hours

    4%

    More than 3, up to 4 hours

    1%

    More than 4, up to 5 hours

    >1%

    More than 5 hours+

    2%


    Over 1 in 6 (17%) of Brits endure congestion for 31 minutes to 1 hour weekly, around 1 in 10 (9%) spend over 1 hour and up to 2 hours in traffic, while 1 in 12 (8%) face more than 2 hours, up to 6 hours in traffic weekly. 

    Across the UK, drivers’ traffic experience differed and while a significant proportion experienced a limited time stuck in rush hour, others had wasted an extensive amount of time fixed on the road. 

    Worst Cities for Traffic Time

    Additional stats from the survey revealed which of the UK’s residents had the most unpleasant time on the road. Surprisingly, London didn’t take the top spot for the city with the worst traffic time, as Edinburgh residents revealed they actually spent the longest time stuck in traffic. 

    A close second is Leeds, as nearly a quarter of residents said they spend over an hour in traffic each week - despite having a network of one-way roads designed to manage traffic flow.

    London takes third place, while Belfast and Manchester also feature in the top 5 cities whose residents spend the most time in traffic.

    City

    % of people who spend over an hour in traffic each week

    1

    Norwich

    5%

    2

    Plymouth

    6%

    3

    Sheffield

    7%

    4

    Newcastle

    8%

    5

    Cardiff

    9%

    By contrast, people in Norwich said they spent the least amount of time stuck in traffic, as only 5% said they spent over an hour in travel congestion every week. 

    Traffic levels are up, but still down from pre-pandemic

    The impact the pandemic has had on traffic levels has been significant, as people across the world were confined to their homes during a series of worldwide lockdowns. Although many Brits have returned to work and their daily routine as usual, many have adopted a new schedule entirely. 

    According to Gov.uk, cars account for 75% of all motor vehicle traffic on British roads over the year ending June 2023. Van traffic has increased in recent years, accounting for 18% of all motor vehicle traffic in these 12 months, lorries account for 5% of all motor vehicle traffic and 1% of traffic came from other motor vehicles including motorcycles and buses.

    Recent stats from the year ending September 2023 revealed:

    • Car traffic was higher than the previous year but still below pre-pandemic levels
    • Van traffic was higher than the previous year and above pre-pandemic levels
    • Lorry traffic was lower than the previous year and similar to pre-pandemic levels

    Vehicle type

    Year ending

    Sep 2023

    Sep 2022

    (previous year)

    Dec 2019

    (pre-pandemic)

    Sep 2018

    (5 years ago)

    All motor vehicles

    329.6

    billion

    2.30%

    -2.70%

    -1.10%

    Cars and taxis

    248.1

    billion

    2.20%

    -5.60%

    -3.90%

    Vans

    59.4

    billion

    3.90%

    11.10%

    12.50%

    Lorries

    17.1

    billion

    -2.30%

    -0.40%

    -0.30%

    Has working from home reduced how many of us are on the road?

    Due to new flexible or remote work policies, cycle-to-work schemes and car-sharing initiatives, many Brits are experiencing less traffic during rush hours.

    According to YouGov, in 2023, 1 in 6 (17%) of workers said they work from home all the time, while a third (33%) say they do so some of the time. With half of workers saying they work from home, there have been fewer commuters on the road during rush hours. This reduction in the number of commuters directly contributes to decreased traffic congestion.

    Others are adopting more flexible schedules which also amounts to a reduction in traffic as Brits may be choosing to start their work day earlier or later to avoid peak traffic times. This further disperses the flow of traffic throughout the day and reduces congestion during traditional rush hours.

    Not only that but, with fewer people commuting to work, there is less demand for parking spaces too. Reduced demand for parking can lead to less traffic congestion around popular parking areas in and around city centres.

    Traffic Offenders 

    Craven Arms in Shropshire has the worst average delay time in the UK 

    Ever found yourself stuck in what feels like an endless stream of brake lights? Some Brits experience it worse than others, as recent DfT stats reveal where in the UK has the worst delay time. 

    The Top 20 Worst Roads for Traffic in the UK

    According to the Department for Transport, the A49 northbound route in Shrewsbury, stretching from the B4368 near Craven Arms (north) to the A489, claims the title of the slowest stretch of road in the UK. Traffic moves at an average speed of merely 8.4 miles per hour and has the highest average delay time of 304.8 seconds per vehicle per mile.


    Nearest Town/City

    County

    Length of Road (metres)

    Area Name

    Road Name

    Avg Delay (secs per vehicle per mile)

    1

    Craven Arms

    Shropshire

    56

    A49 northbound between B4368 near Craven Arms (north) and A489

    A49

    304.8

    2

    Rochdale

    Greater Manchester

    70

    A627(M) northbound between M62 and A664 near Rochdale

    A627 (M)

    264.4

    3

    Newtown

    Powys

    55

    A49 southbound between A489 and B4368 near Craven Arms (north)

    A49

    210.2

    4

    Thirsk

    North Yorkshire

    81

    A19 southbound between A1 and A1068

    A19

    194.3

    5

    Eastbourne

    East Sussex

    139

    A27 eastbound within the A2270 junction

    A27

    165.9

    6

    Sheffield

    South Yorkshire

    27

    A616 westbound at a minor junction between A6102 and A628

    A616

    164.5

    7

    Dartford

    Kent

    33

    A282 northbound within the A206 junction

    M25

    161.9

    8

    Hereford

    Herefordshire

    385

    A49 northbound between B4224 and A4103

    A49

    160.5

    9

    Royal Tunbridge Wells

    Kent

    56

    A27 westbound between A26 and A26

    A27

    159.1

    10

    Eastleigh

    Hampshire

    111

    A335 southbound within M3 J12

    A335

    152.7

    11

    Chichester

    West Sussex

    437

    A27 westbound between A285 near Chichester (west) and B2144

    A27

    151.6

    12

    Bicester

    Oxfordshire

    273

    A404 northbound within M40 junction

    A404

    149.2

    13

    Hereford

    Herefordshire

    137

    A49 northbound between A438 near Hereford (south) and A438 near Hereford (north)

    A49

    148.8

    14

    Warwick

    Warwickshire

    72

    A46 southbound within the M40 junction

    A46

    143.3

    15

    Barnsley

    South Yorkshire

    68

    A616 westbound at a minor junction between A6102 and A628

    A616

    141.2

    16

    Ashford

    Kent

    963

    A2070 southbound between M20 and A2042

    A2070

    139.5

    17

    Ashford

    Surrey

    26

    A30 westbound between B378 and A308

    A30

    137.4

    18

    Northampton

    Northamptonshire

    781

    A5 northbound between A422/A508 and A43

    A5

    133.3

    19

    Cranbrook

    Kent

    240

    A21 southbound between B2160 and A262

    A21

    130

    20

    Gloucester

    Gloucestershire

    43

    A40 westbound within the A417 junction near Gloucester (north)

    A40

    127.5


    From slow stretches of country roads to speedy main roads, the A49 (which features the slowest UK road) is also known for its range in speeds - causing dangerous road incidents.

    In the Ludlow Advertiser, Shropshire councillor for Ludlow South, Vivienne Parry said: "The A49 is one of the most dangerous roads in the country and there have been many deaths,” 

    If there is a problem with the A49 then it is traffic going too fast. It is a dangerous stretch of road partly because there is a mix of traffic with some cars going very fast along with slow vehicles like tractors but that is what happens in the countryside.”

    Other roads that feature in the top five include a section on the A627 (M) in Rochdale, another area of the A49 in Newtown, a section of the A19 southbound in Thirsk and a section on the A27 eastbound in Eastbourne. 

    Top 20 Worst Areas in the UK for Collisions

    Collisions can happen on busy city streets or quiet country roads but latest Gov.uk data reveals the areas where accidents take place most frequently. 

    Taking the top spot for car accidents is Kent which had the most vehicle collisions, the latest data revealed there were 3,457 incidents in this area in 2021.

    Local authority

    Region or Country

    All Collisions

    1

    Kent

    South East

    3,457

    2

    Surrey

    South East

    2,783

    3

    Birmingham

    West Midlands

    2,383

    4

    Essex

    East of England

    2,377

    5

    Hampshire

    South East

    2,278

    6

    Lancashire

    North West

    2,159

    7

    West Sussex

    South East

    1,826

    8

    Hertfordshire

    East of England

    1,780

    9

    Lincolnshire

    East Midlands

    1,604

    10

    Leeds

    Yorkshire and The Humber

    1,585

    11

    Norfolk

    East of England

    1,537

    12

    Derbyshire

    East Midlands

    1,462

    13

    Westminster

    London

    1,274

    14

    East Sussex

    South East

    1,216

    15

    Nottinghamshire

    East Midlands

    1,210

    16

    Devon

    South West

    1,199

    17

    Lambeth

    London

    1,167

    18

    Suffolk

    East of England

    1,163

    19

    Cambridgeshire

    East of England

    1,094

    20

    Bradford

    Yorkshire and The Humber

    1,062

     

    When looking at data, Kent places first for the most vehicle collisions. Busy roads and its proximity to London mean it’s a hotspot for traffic, which could be part of the reason for its high number of collisions.

    A Freedom of Information request by CarMats.co.uk also revealed that Kent had the highest number of drink drivers as a reported 181 drivers failed their breathalyser tests in 2022, compared to only 44 drink drivers in Birmingham, which came in third place. This could be another reason for the high number of car accidents. 

    Worst Types of Roads & Speed Limits for Collisions

    Built up roads with 30MPH speed limits have the most accidents 

    When it comes to road safety, understanding the correlation between road types, speed limits, and collision rates is key. Using Gov.uk data, research reveals the characteristics of roads that pose the greatest risks for accidents. 

    Types of roads and their collision rates

    Type of road

    Speed limit (MPH)

    Number of collisions

    1

    Built up

    30

    57226

    2

    Built up

    20

    16447

    3

    Non built up

    60

    12472

    4

    Built up

    40

    9062

    5

    Non built up

    50

    4349

    6

    Motorways

    70

    3435

    7

    Non built up

    70

    3013

    Built-up roads with a speed limit of 30 mph had the highest number of collisions overall. Several factors could be the cause of the incidents - as built-up areas tend to have higher population densities, this can lead to increased traffic volume on roads. With more vehicles sharing limited road space, the likelihood of collisions can rise.

    Despite the lower speed limits typically imposed in built-up areas (such as the 30 mph limit), compliance with these limits can vary among drivers. Some may exceed the speed limit, while others may adhere to the appropriate speed. The combination of differing speeds within close proximity can increase the likelihood of collisions, especially at intersections and areas with distractions and limited visibility.

    Men caused more accidents than women

    Road user type

    Sex

    All drivers

    Car drivers

    Male

    28,775

    Car drivers

    Female

    22,600


    As well as road type, Gov.uk data also revealed which gender was to blame for the most accidents. Of all drivers, men were 27% more likely to cause a crash; this higher rate was also supported by the CarMats.co.uk study which revealed 14% of men admitted to causing a car accident, compared to only 7% of women. 

    Men and women in their 30s caused the most car accidents 

    This study delved into who's behind the wheel of car accidents in the UK and Gov.uk research found that that men and women in their 30s were the cause of the most collisions. By contrast, the study found that the UK’s oldest and youngest female drivers are involved in the fewest accidents.

    Sex

    Age group 

    Collisions

    Male

    30 to 39

    6,169

    Female

    30 to 39

    5,120

    Male

    40 to 49

    4,686

    Female

    40 to 49

    4,014

    Male

    50 to 59

    3,955

    Female

    50 to 59

    3,497

    Male

    25 to 29

    3,261

    Male

    70 and over

    2,720

    Male

    21 to 24

    2,707

    Female

    25 to 29

    2,689

    Male

    17 to 20

    2,611

    Male

    60 to 69

    2,339

    Female

    21 to 24

    2,016

    Female

    60 to 69

    1,806

    Female

    70 and over

    1,752

    Female

    17 to 20

    1,531

    Millennial men were responsible for the most accidents and were behind the wheel of over 6,000 collisions - millennial women followed slightly behind as they were responsible for 5,120 collisions. 

    The UK’s youngest and oldest female drivers were the most cautious motorists as they each were responsible for less than 2,000 collisions, as reported in the latest Government data.

    Peugeot drivers admit to causing the most crashes 

    Following research from the CarMats.co.uk study, stats revealed which drivers were the worst traffic offenders.

    In a survey of over 1,200 drivers, over 1 in 5 (21%) Peugeot drivers admitted that they were the cause of a car accident they were involved in, this was compared to only 7% of BMW drivers. 

    Skoda, Aston Martin, Mercedes-Benz, and SEAT drivers were also among those who ranked highly for causing a significant number of car accidents.

    Train Delays & Commuter Chaos 

    Train delays and cancellations have become increasingly common occurrences for passengers across Britain. Strikes, coping with the demand, aged infrastructure and rail issues are all factors causing schedule setbacks and commuter chaos - but which stations and operators have the worst track record?

    The study examines the most frequently used stations in each region based on the Office of Rail & Road statistics and assesses their efficiency using On Time Trains data to determine which railways are performing the most and least effectively.

    Top 20 Worst Train Stations for Delays 

    Durham has the least efficient train services 

    Brits have become accustomed to train delays, but some areas of the UK experience delays worse than others. 

    Of the top 20 worst train stations for delays, Durham ranks first place. The University town grapples with the reputation of having the region's least efficient train network.

    Station

    Region

    Punctuality Ranking

    1

    Durham

    North East

    66%

    2

    Swindon (Wiltshire)

    South West

    67%

    3

    Swansea

    Wales

    68%

    4

    Newport (South Wales)

    Wales

    69%

    5

    Bridgend

    Wales

    69%

    6

    Berwick-upon-Tweed

    North East

    69%

    7

    York

    Yorkshire & The Humber

    71%

    8

    Huddersfield

    Yorkshire & The Humber

    71%

    9

    Coventry

    West Midlands

    73%

    10

    Bath Spa

    South West

    73%

    11

    Darlington

    North East

    73%

    12

    Wolverhampton

    West Midlands

    74%

    13

    Manchester Piccadilly

    North West

    75%

    14

    Sheffield

    Yorkshire & The Humber

    75%

    15

    Newcastle

    North East

    75%

    16

    Manchester Victoria

    North West

    75%

    17

    Leicester

    East Midlands

    75%

    18

    Bristol Temple Meads

    South West

    76%

    19

    Birmingham International

    West Midlands

    76%

    20

    Derby

    East Midlands

    76%

    Data by On Time Trains reveals that the most popular stations in the North of England, the Midlands, and Wales have the least efficient services, as they feature in the 20 worst performing stations. This included stations such as Swansea, York and Coventry. Poor punctuality left the bottom 5 with an inadequate punctuality score of less than 70% last year.

    Most Efficient British Train Stations 

    Chelmsford has the timeliest services in Britain

    The On Time Trains data revealed Chelmsford, in Essex, stands out as a beacon of reliability in Britain's railway network. With a score of 95% efficiency, Chelmsford boasts some of the timeliest train services of the 55 most popular across the country. 


    Station

    Region

    Punctuality Ranking

    1

    Chelmsford

    East of England

    95%

    2

    London Liverpool Street

    London

    93%

    3

    Stratford

    London

    92%

    4

    Stansted Airport

    East of England

    92%

    5

    Cardiff Queen Street

    Wales

    92%

    6

    Tottenham Court Road

    London

    91%

    7

    Liverpool Central

    North West

    90%

    8

    Moorfields

    North West

    90%

    9

    Glasgow Central

    Scotland

    89%

    10

    Paisley Gilmour Street

    Scotland

    89%

    11

    London Waterloo

    London

    88%

    12

    London Victoria

    London

    88%

    13

    London Bridge

    London

    87%

    14

    Glasgow Queen Street

    Scotland

    87%

    15

    Cambridge

    East of England

    87%

    16

    Farringdon

    London

    86%

    17

    Brighton

    South East

    86%

    18

    Birmingham Moor Street

    West Midlands

    86%

    19

    Lincoln

    East Midlands

    85%

    20

    Edinburgh Waverley

    Scotland

    84%

    The South of England and Scotland appear to have the most efficient services as 15 of the top 20 feature in the list of the most efficient services. 

    Busiest stations in Great Britain 

    London Liverpool Street is the busiest station in the UK

    With a staggering 80,400,000 visits annually, London Liverpool Street claims the title of the UK's busiest train station. Serving as the capital's prime hub, it attracts countless commuters, tourists, and travellers. It is among the top 10 stations, all of which are located in London.


    Station

    Region

    Entries & Exits

    1

    London Liverpool Street

    London

    80,400,000

    2

    London Paddington

    London

    59,200,000

    3

    London Waterloo

    London

    57,800,000

    4

    London Bridge

    London

    47,700,000

    5

    London Victoria

    London

    45,600,000

    6

    Stratford

    London

    44,100,000

    7

    Tottenham Court Road

    London

    34,900,000

    8

    London St Pancras International

    London

    33,300,000

    9

    Farringdon

    London

    31,500,000

    10

    London Euston

    London

    31,300,000

    11

    Birmingham New Street

    West Midlands

    30,700,000

    12

    Leeds

    Yorkshire & The Humber

    24,000,000

    13

    Manchester Piccadilly

    North West

    23,600,000

    14

    Glasgow Central

    Scotland

    20,800,000

    15

    Edinburgh Waverley

    Scotland

    18,200,000

    16

    Gatwick Station

    South East

    16,500,000

    17

    Brighton

    South East

    14,100,000

    18

    Reading

    South East

    12,400,000

    19

    Glasgow Queen Street

    Scotland

    12,300,000

    20

    Liverpool Central

    North West

    11,400,000

    Outside of London, Birmingham New Street takes top spot for the busiest station and features among other popular stations such as Leeds station and Manchester Piccadilly. 

    The Worst Train Operators in the UK 

    Grand Central is the least efficient rail operator in the UK

    When it comes to train travel in the UK, not all operators are created equal. Some have gained a reputation for being the worst in the business. 

    Using data from the Office of Rail & Road, during Q1 and Q2 of 2023 - 2024, this study reveals which rail operators are leaving passengers the most dissatisfied. 

    From frequent delays to cancellations, the Grand Central rail service has ranked poorly for its time efficiency, coming in top spot for the least number of on-time trains and the most number of cancellations. 


    Train Line

    Train Services That Left On Time

    Cancellations

    1

    Grand Central

    46%

    7%

    2

    Avanti West Coast

    46%

    4%

    3

    Cross Country

    49%

    7%

    4

    Transpennine Express

    50%

    5%

    5

    East Midlands

    54%

    2%

    6

    Hull Trains

    55%

    1%

    7

    TfW Rail

    59%

    6%

    8

    London North Eastern Railway

    60%

    3%

    9

    Lumo

    60%

    1%

    10

    Great Western Railway

    61%

    4%

    11

    Northern Trains

    62%

    5%

    12

    West Midlands Train

    63%

    4%

    13

    Southeastern

    70%

    2%

    14

    Govia Thamesway Link

    72%

    4%

    15

    South Western Railway

    72%

    3%

    16

    Merseyrail

    73%

    2%

    17

    Scot Rail

    73%

    2%

    18

    Caledonian Sleeper

    74%

    2%

    19

    London Overground

    75%

    3%

    20

    Chiltern Railways

    78%

    2%

    21

    Heathrow Express

    78%

    3%

    22

    c2c

    80%

    1%

    23

    Elizabeth Line

    83%

    4%

    24

    Greater Anglia

    87%

    1%

    Also featuring in the top 5 is Cross Country (which scored the same high score as the Grand Central for its cancellation rate), Avanti West Coast, Transpennine Express and East Midlands rail.

    By contrast, the Great Anglia train operator had the most efficient service in the UK with 87% of its trains running on time and only a 1% cancellation rate. 

    Conclusion

    The Travel Disruptions Study shows that when it comes to delays, Brits face obstruction on a daily basis. It reveals that delays have become an all too common occurrence, disrupting the routines of individuals whether they are travelling via road or rail. 

    These travel delays not only cause inconvenience but also contribute to increased potential disruptions to daily schedules. As such, the study sheds light on the offenders behind some of the UK’s worst causes of traffic and travel delays. 

    These insights remind us that addressing these issues is key to improving the overall quality of transportation infrastructure and enhancing the commuting experience for all.

    Methodology

    1. Driving Habits study - Research conducted by CarMats.co.uk team who surveyed 1,366 UK drivers using Censuswide
    2. The traffic lifetime stat was calculated by finding out the time lost per year then multiplying that by the average lifetime (82 years) minus the minimum driving age (17 years). 
    3. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/road-traffic-estimates-in-great-britain-2022/road-traffic-estimates-in-great-britain-2022-headline-statistics
    4. https://yougov.co.uk/society/articles/47779-half-of-workers-now-working-from-home-at-least-some-of-the-time
    5. https://dft.maps.arcgis.com/apps/webappviewer/index.html?id=7dc08398c2934ef99284a575b948f7de
    6. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/reported-road-accidents-vehicles-and-casualties-tables-for-great-britain#geographical-breakdowns-ras04

    Fair use statement 

    If you want to share our study, any findings or images from the study, please credit with a link to this page.


    Share this post



    ← Older Post